Disco de All That Remains: “Live in Philadelphia”

I have been a huge ATR fan for years. This movie is the best live DVD from a band that I have ever seen. It is like you are at the concert in Philly or at the concert in Baltimore. If you have ever seen ATR live then you know this is a must buy. Especially for viewing in between concerts.

I received this a day ago, and just wow! It is a must have for any All That Remains have, I loved all the extras, i found out so much about the band i didn't know. I would recommend this to all All That Remains fans!

There are two live sets included on this DVD. Overall I'd give it a 4.5 if I could but I'll round up to be nice.

Maryland: B- There are many good songs in this performance, which is nice. However it suffers from somewhat poor sound quality (at least compared to the Philly show). The mix - especially Oli's lead work in some of the solos, is off and frankly hard to listen to at points. Also, Phil seems a bit more tired than usual. But overall, this band is awesome and the songs make up for the shortcomings in this performance.

Philly: A- This was an excellent show. The sounds quality is noticeably better than the Maryland show (try switching between the two), and they just seem tighter in general. The mix problems have been fixed, and Phil is 100%. It's hard to find much to criticize in this performance - the only things I notice are that Jason still struggles with timing in parts of 'Six', and that 'The Weak Willed' and 'This Calling' are missing from this performance. That's no problem, however, because those songs are on the Maryland show.

Extras: Usually I'm less interested in these, but I found it interesting to "get to know" some of the band members and see how down to earth they are, especially in contrast to some of their fans, which is kind of funny.

If you're at all a fan of ATR, I highly recommend this live DVD.

2 great shows on this dvd, this dvd is awesome, The only negative is that the auio could of been a little better but if your a fan its a must have,,!

This is one of the live best bands out now.I've seen them twice and have yet to be disappointed.Having said that,I was very excited when I heard about this.

Production picture wise is pretty good,but I think the sound engineer dropped the ball.Oli Herbert's leads are conspicuously absent.You can see he's playing,but can't hear him at all.I like this band enough to buy this but just wished they would've taken more time and made it perfect for their loyal fans.