I was fine, just a guy
Living on my own
Waiting for the sky to fall
Then you called
And changed it all, doll
Velvet lips and the eyes to pull me in
We both knew you'd already win
Mmm, your original sin.

You fooled me once with your eyes now honey
You fooled me twice with your lies and I say

Sarah smiles like Sarah doesn't care
She lives in her world so unaware
Does she know that my destiny lies with her?
Sarah (Sarah, Sarah, Sarah)
Oh Sarah (Sarah)
Are you sinning me?

Waking up to a kiss
And your on your way
I really hoped that you would stay
But you left and went your own way, babe
I don't mind, take your time
I got things to do
Besides sit around and wait for you
Oh, and I hope you do too

You fooled me once with your eyes now honey
You fooled me twice with your lies and I say

Sarah smiles like Sarah doesn't care
She lives in her world so unaware
Does she know that my destiny lies with her?
Sarah
Oh Sarah
Are you sinning me?

And it's killing me inside (hey hey hey)
Consuming all my time
You've left me blind
And when I think I'm right
You strip away my pride
You cast it all aside
But I say

Sarah smiles like Sarah doesn't care
She lives in her world so unaware
Does she know that my destiny lies with her?
Sarah (Sarah)
Oh Sarah (Sarah)
Are you sinning me?